Contact

Don’t Count on It

By

August 1, 2017

Image titel:

Sources:

Don’t Count on It

In late March, Dieter Zetsche’s words on electric transportation and the future of fuel cells caused quite a stir in the automotive industry. During the auto motor und sport conference on March 27 in Stuttgart, the head of Daimler was asked about what type of electric transportation his company would favor over the coming years. Instead of the short reply one would expect, he went on to give a long answer to the question and it seemed to have given rise to wildly different interpretations.

Before the day was over, a headline on T-Online read: “Daimler says goodbye to hydrogen.” In the article, it said: “The fuel cell is now no longer a central part of Daimler’s renewable strategy.” As proof, the web portal offered a quote by Zetsche himself: “I believe one would be well advised to focus on battery-electric vehicles over the next ten years.” But the second half of the sentence – clearing up the misunderstanding – had been omitted (see long quote Daimler Stays).

Advertisements

About the benefits of fuel cells – greater range and faster refueling – T-Online wrote: “Recent developments in battery technologies have reduced those advantages. Whereas batteries are getting ever cheaper, hydrogen production is as expensive as ever.” But ultimately, the article ended with the conclusion that “fuel cells remain an interesting technological option.”

A day later, Automobil Produktion wrote: “Daimler head Zetsche says fuel cell has few benefits.” In the article, it said: “Fuel cells are no longer at the heart of Daimler’s alternative engine strategy.”

Advertisements

In early April, iwr.de wrote: “Daimler and Vaillant turn their backs on fuel cells.” golem.de even speculated about a possible end to the 2013 fuel cell agreement between Daimler, Ford and Renault-Nissan.

The high point, though, was the “Obituary for the Fuel Cell” published in the Wirtschaftswoche business magazine just before Hannover Messe – death notice included (see Daimler Stays). The authors chose somewhat melodramatic phrases such as: “Hydrogen technology: Rest gently.”

The opinion piece by editors Martin Seiwert and Stefan Hajek did show knowledge of the industry, but left no doubt as to their love for battery-driven electric transportation and their dislike of fuel cells, saying that the automotive industry “paid dearly for its fuel cell mistake.” They deemed Elon Musk a “genius who is very much alive and well,” while “the pretty engineering vision of fuel cell use collides with hard economic facts.”

The authors’ statement that “the electric car has meanwhile caught up with FCEVs regarding range and total environmental impact” seems a bit premature. As does the claim that battery vehicles were “much cheaper.”

When H2-international asked Wirtschaftswoche who’s digging the fuel cell’s grave, Seiwert replied: “We are, based on the reasons and conclusions we presented in our article. Mister Zetsche has said the right thing; others aren’t that courageous, since they have invested billions in the technology.” And the “year of birth” was given as 1966 (see obituary: Daimler Stays) because that was the year General Motors had unveiled its first fuel cell car.

Journalists seem to use increasingly drastic language and ever more dramatic phrases in their reporting and they have been right on target. The hydrogen and fuel cell community seemed very uneasy during Hannover Messe (see Confident About Upcoming Commercialization); despite an overall positive mood at the industrial fair, the above-mentioned news did dampen enthusiasm quite a bit.

Even Daimler’s press office was surprised – not by Zetsche’s statement, but by the news that followed. It offered a clarification to H2-international, saying that there “have been no changes to our current strategy. […] We need hydrogen. […] Daimler sees a future for the fuel cell.”

In the end, the carmaker will stick with its plan to unveil a new FCEV, the GLC F-CELL, this year and start production in small numbers (presumably around 1,000 units in 2018).

However, it is no longer about Daimler, even if the carmaker’s Stuttgart press office appreciated Hydrogeit Verlag publishing a correction on its HZwei blog.

Zetsche’s words and their differing interpretations made it clear that the battle about which was the better, more future-proof technology has already been raging for a while – despite statements to the contrary. For a long time, politicians and NOW have tried to pass off electric transportation as a joint project of battery and fuel cell suppliers. But the fact of the matter is that the potential revenue streams mean everyone will use any means necessary to up their market share. The Wirtschaftswoche editors have realized that.

Whoever or whatever provided the impetus for their opinion piece, their article will only be the first in an ugly fight between battery and fuel cell advocates, something that has already been on full display on social media.

Here are interesting and current articles on the topic of hydrogen – stocks and the stock market!

Economic prospects for companies in the hydrogen sector | Future, stocks & hydrogen companies on the stock exchange and more…

Which hydrogen companies will prevail in the competitive market in the long term? Get tips and cartwheels and learn more about risks or opportunities. Our stock market specialist and expert author Sven Jösting reports critically, independently and competently.

Mar 18 2024

Search for the ideal hydrogen storage

Interview with Thomas Korn, CEO of water stuff & sun Startup company water stuff & sun has...
Mar 15 2024

Is exponential growth slowing down?

Fuel Cell Industry Review 2022 Year 2022 saw fuel cell shipments creep up over 2021 numbers,...
Mar 11 2024

On the way to becoming a green hydrogen partner

Oman aims to score points with H2 infrastructure Wind, sun and loads of expertise – these...
Mar 07 2024

We can master a scale-up for green hydrogen

Interview with Dr. Kai Fischer, Director at RWTH Aachen The efficient scaling of green hydrogen...
Mar 07 2024

Frustration over continuing uncertainties

Interview with Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, CEO of Hydrogen Europe There is a lot that needs sorting out...
Mar 05 2024

“If ever there was momentum for hydrogen, it is now”

Interview with Dr. Jochen Köckler, chairman of Deutsche Messe “We’re bringing people together.”...
Feb 28 2024

H2Direkt: Blueprint for heating with pure H2

The energy providers Thüga und Energie Südbayern (ESB) as well as Energienetze Bayern have...
Feb 26 2024

Just switch over?

Hydrogen in the existing natural gas network Whether hydrogen contributes to the clean heating...
Feb 26 2024

Pilot plant for coating bipolar plates

At Fraunhofer FEP (Fraunhofer-Institut für Organische Elektronik, Elektronenstrahl- und...
Feb 20 2024

55 MW electrolyzer to decarbonize Saarland

Hydrogen Regions series: HydroHub Fenne living lab The power plant site in Fenne, Völklingen, a...
Feb 20 2024

Chicken feathers as FC membrane material

Feathers from chickens or other poultry could in the future help make fuel cells more effective...
Feb 15 2024

SMEs demand more security

Guest article by André Steinau, CEO of GP Joule Hydrogen After all, the Ampel Coalition leading...
Feb 15 2024

Accelerated expansion of renewable energies

RED III is here – Elsewhere, the wait continues Progress is being made at EU level – albeit...
Feb 12 2024

Picea 2 relies on lithium instead of lead

HPS presents new product generation The company HPS Home Power Solutions has unveiled a new...
Feb 12 2024

H2 production by photocatalysis

The direct generation of hydrogen from sunlight has long been considered the most elegant solution...
Feb 05 2024

Regional instead of international

Hy-Fcell has it difficult asserting itself The aspiration of Landesmesse Stuttgart with Hy-Fcell...
Feb 01 2024

Hydrogeit Verlag turns 20 years old

Hydrogeit Verlag is proudly celebrating its 20th anniversary as a renowned specialist publisher in...
Jan 26 2024

Stracke other H2Now managing director

BMV Energy GmbH is entering the market as another player in hydrogen refueling stations. The...
Jan 26 2024

Starting points for a comprehensive hydrogen ramp-up

Industry congress GAT 2023 in Cologne To establish a functioning hydrogen economy, the entire...
Jan 26 2024

The industry highpoint in autumn

Hydrogen Technology Expo total success In autumn 2023 as well, the Hydrogen Technology Expo was...

0 Comments

Leave a Reply